Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Neural Foundry's avatar

Really powerful reminder that participation in litrugical music isn't just about singing along but attuning ourselves to the rite itself. The distinction betwee what we do versus what God does for us through liturgy tends to get lost when music selection becomes more about audience engagement than vertical worship.

adrienneep's avatar

We have a small semi-rural Oregon parish. Our pastor is one of two in our regional area who does the Latin Mass weekly at 30 mikes away at another parish, but it has always been at 3:30 on Sunday. That tends to reduce the attendance, especially in the winter. But our local parish is still deep in the tyranny of outrageously expensive and copyrighted OCP/GIA missals. Those choir teams apparently get their marching orders from the “helpful” OCP/GIA marketing department. They saw fit to use a modern music version of O Come Emmanuel at Advent and it ruined my four weeks. And this is the diocese with Archbishop Sample who wrote brilliant letters regarding use of sacred music at his former diocese. The new bishop of Marquette took those letters and helped the diocese formulate its own reverent hymnal over five years. But no, here in Portland diocese the All Are Welcome tyranny continues apace even years later.

You might enjoy this expose about the Hymnal Industrial Complex.

https://www.lepantoin.org/wp/the-hymnal-industrial-complex/

8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?